Yet more on D6 Weapon Damage

Blood of Prokopius posts on the D6 weapon damage thing, making this point:

Having d6 damage has given my players the freedom to use weapons that they wouldn’t otherwise use. The main party fighter uses a spiked club, which he is very attached to. Once variable weapon damage is introduced (especially as written in AD&D) fighters almost always go for swords — why settle for club at d4 damage when the long sword does d8? In practice, the universal d6 damage has resulted in creative play — since everything does d6 damage, advantage in combat comes from tactical choices outside of weapon choice. As a gamer, I’ve really enjoyed this creativity — aesthetics.

Often, particularly with NPCs, I assign “other” weapons as a sort of characterization. This is really cool in my mind, but then the NPC finds itself over-matched in combat because the PCs all have optimum (dice-wise) weapons. Which is a bummer.

Again, I really like the idea of all-D6 weapon damage, but it doesn’t work so well when the system uses hit dice greater than D6.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Yet more on D6 Weapon Damage

  1. bat says:

    And I still agree.
    With S&W White Box, this is a great idea.
    With most anything else, this does make monsters tougher and harder to kill, which does make dragons and giants more epic, which isn’t a bad thing, either, but then experience point values should be altered to reflect this new aspect of the game.

    By the way, it is good to see you posting again.

Comments are closed.